1
General Discussion / Preselected, qualified judges for NPS?
« on: August 19, 2009, 11:42:40 AM »
Considering the amount of preparation and effort at the local and national level, why don't we assemble a pool of qualified judges from academia, slam, pop culture, maybe even a celebrity or two?
It could be a pool of approximately 60 judges to work the NPS tournament. Since there are usually no more than five bouts at a time, judges could work two bouts a night in different venues. Doesn't matter where they're from, as they will judge based on the poetry and performance. There are a lot of variables, but I'm hoping to hear amid many shouts of Are you crazy? and You don't know what you're talking about! some thoughts as to why this could possibly work.
I base this on two things:
1. The struggle to find an unbiased, random judge from the audience at an NPS bout.
2. Steve Marsh's writing "... some of our judges come from all over the country to sit in that bar to be a judge. They are not random at all" in another thread.
It could be a pool of approximately 60 judges to work the NPS tournament. Since there are usually no more than five bouts at a time, judges could work two bouts a night in different venues. Doesn't matter where they're from, as they will judge based on the poetry and performance. There are a lot of variables, but I'm hoping to hear amid many shouts of Are you crazy? and You don't know what you're talking about! some thoughts as to why this could possibly work.
I base this on two things:
1. The struggle to find an unbiased, random judge from the audience at an NPS bout.
2. Steve Marsh's writing "... some of our judges come from all over the country to sit in that bar to be a judge. They are not random at all" in another thread.